It Walks By Night by John Dickson Carr

Deliciously decadent…

😀 😀 😀 😀 😀

Young Jeff Marle has been summoned to Paris by an old friend of his father: the legendary detective Henri Bencolin, director of the Paris police. Bencolin has a peculiar case on his hands and feels Jeff may be interested in observing his methods. So Jeff becomes our “Watson”, and it’s through his eyes that we see the great detective at work. The case involves a madman – perhaps these days we would say psychopath – Alexandre Laurent, who was locked up after trying to kill his young and beautiful wife, Louise. That wife, her first marriage annulled, is now about to get married again, to the famous all-round sporting legend, Raoul de Saligny. But Laurent has escaped and rumour has it that he may have visited a plastic surgeon to change his appearance. He has sent a letter warning Raoul not to marry Louise and Bencolin fears that he will turn up in Paris, bent on killing Raoul and possibly Louise too. On the night of their wedding day, Raoul, Louise and the wedding party go to a fashionable gambling house, and Bencolin has his men there in force to guard them. But Laurent has the true cunning intelligence of the madman…

This is Carr’s first mystery novel, and my first introduction to his work. I thought it was totally marvellous! There are a couple of plots weaknesses, some moments where you have to take a deep breath and just let your suspension of disbelief have full rein, and it occasionally goes over the top into high melodrama. But the writing is great, and Carr creates a wonderfully creepy, almost hallucinatory atmosphere of horror and tension. In fact, it seemed to me draw as much, if not more, on the tradition of the Decadent horror writing of the fin de siècle period as on the mystery conventions of the Golden Age.

Published in 1930 and set in Paris, it offers a darker take on the “lost generation” of that time – of those living after one devastating war and seeing the approaching inevitability of another on the horizon. There is a great sense of amorality, of sensuous egoism, of a kind of cruelty of empty friendships and brutal infidelities. Drugs and drink play their part in the glittering hopelessness of the characters’ lives, and even in Jeff’s observations. One scene, where he has dinner with a young woman caught up in the case, is a masterpiece of fear heightened by the befuddling effects of alcohol – Poe-like in its creation of an atmosphere of impending horror. Grand Guignol was in my mind for much of it, since there’s no holding back in the gruesome bloodiness of the crimes, nor the pointless cruelty of them.

John Dickson Carr

As a mystery, I do think it’s just about fair play, although one has to be willing to let one’s imagination run riot a bit. There’s a locked room aspect to it, and as usual I failed to get that at all and frankly felt the solution to that part of the mystery was a bit too contrived. But in terms of the whodunit aspects – in this case, the who-is-Laurent aspect – I spotted several of the clues without realising that that’s what they were; in fact, I had sort of thought they were accidental inconsistencies rather than clues until all was explained at the end. But when the solution comes it’s wonderfully twisted, carrying the atmosphere of decadent horror right through to the end.

I’m aware that part of the reason I loved it so much is because of the horror aspects and that this may not appeal to all Golden Age mystery fans as much as it does to me. But the mystery aspect is good too and while Bencolin can be a bit too full of himself, as many of the great detectives are, Jeff is a wonderfully original creation as Watsons go, becoming deeply involved not just in the investigation but in the characters’ lives and the playing out of the plot. Wonderful stuff, and I can’t wait now to read more Carr – no wonder he’s considered one of the greats.

NB This book was provided for review by the publisher, the British Library.

Amazon UK Link
Amazon US Link

22 thoughts on “It Walks By Night by John Dickson Carr

  1. That, to me, is one of Carr’s talents, FictionFan. He did such a good job of evoking a deliciously creepy atmosphere. And his puzzles are fascinating, too – and some of them are absolutely brilliant. Admittedly, there are times when you have to let your disbelief take a walk. But for people who can do that, Carr did put together some great stories. I look forward to what you think of Three Coffins/The Hollow Man when/if you get to it.


    • I wasn’t expecting it to be creepy so it took me completely by surprise, and tingled my spine more than a lot of the actual horror I’ve read! I never manage to work out locked room mysteries but this one had a whodunit aspect as well as the “how” and I did work out one part of it so was able to feel a little bit smug. Ooh, The Hollow Man is the one in my Murder, Mystery, Mayhem challenge so I’m thrilled you think it’s one of the good ones – must get to it soon! 😀

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I’ve not read Carr before, but this one sounds interesting. Not sure I’d appreciate all the horror elements, but it might be a nice change from some of the things I’ve been reading.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I know he’s considered one of the greats, but for some reason have never tried him before. My mistake! I assume not all his books have this creepy side to them but it worked brilliantly in this one… 😀

      Liked by 1 person

  3. The title sounds faintly familiar, but I don’t think I’d ever properly heard of this one – it sounds like a wonderfully thrilling read, though. Adding to my TBR…


  4. I love the sound of this one-and i think I mentioned this before, but the whole aspect of having plastic surgery to ‘conceal the criminal’ is absolutely delightful. Although, I didn’t know plastic surgery was a thing back in 1930? The botched surgeries of today always look so awful, I can’t imagine how horrible they were back then hahah


Please leave a comment - I'd love to know who's visiting and what you think...of the post, of the book, of the blog, of life, of chocolate...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.