The Rat Stone Serenade by Denzil Meyrick

Too much of a good thing…

🙂 🙂 🙂

the rat stone serenadeA hundred years ago, blacksmith Nathaniel Stuart was driven off his property in Blaan, a village on the southernmost tip of the remote Kintyre peninsula on the west coast of Scotland. Of tinker stock, Stuart cursed the landowner Archie Shannon, declaring that every fifty years calamity will befall his family and their descendants until the end of time. Fifty years later, young Archie Shannon hid from his mother in the woods behind their home for a lark – and was never seen again. Now, in the present day, the Shannon family is returning to their ancestral home in Blaan for the annual general meeting of the hugely successful international company they now own. But things take a sinister turn when the bones of a young child are discovered on the Rat Stone, an ancient site surrounded by much superstition and fear…

There is so much to like about this book that I really wish I was recommending it more highly. It’s very well written, and the recurring characters of DCI Daley and his small team are done well – each with a distinct personality, each flawed, but all likeable as individuals and working well together as a team. The remoteness of this part of the world is increased when an unusually severe snowstorm cuts off the roads to the mainland and causes power cuts throughout the area. Meyrick creates an excellent atmosphere of isolation and menace, with some nicely spine-tingling supernatural undertones. With no likelihood of reinforcements getting through any time soon, it’s up to Daley and his colleagues not just to investigate the old bones but to try to stop the sudden crime wave that is sweeping through the village.

And therein lies the problem. Too much, too much! The body count is completely ridiculous! For a large proportion of the early part of the book, each chapter introduces us to someone who is then gruesomely killed. It seems like there’s a million strands each resulting in gory death for someone and for a long time, too long, the connection between all these events is entirely unclear. And with so many deaths happening so quickly, these characters are no more than names, so that when they’re referred to later in the book, I was having real difficulties remembering who they were or how and where they died.

The book is like an Irish stew – everything has been thrown in. One detective is an alcoholic trying to lay off the booze, while a couple of the others are having an affair with each other. There are dead businessmen, human sacrifices, dodgy business dealings, vicars with secrets, ex-nuns, tinkers’ curses and about three people all having visions, either supernatural, caused by drink or due to brain damage. Corpses with their skin flayed, corpses on bonfires, corpses on sacrificial stones. Every now and again new people had to arrive by helicopter or boat just to replenish the stock of people to bump off. One felt an investigation wasn’t really necessary – leave it a couple of days and only the bad guy would be left alive!

Denzil Meyrick
Denzil Meyrick

One of the detectives is given what I think is supposed to be a Glasgow accent, though it feels more like an anglicised speaker’s idea of what a generic Scottish dialect sounded like circa 1950 – a bit too Sunday Post (which will mean nothing to non-Scots – sorry! Twee, perhaps, is the closest comparison). However, kudos to the author for at least trying to keep the book feeling Scottish in tone, and I must say my ‘ear’ did get tuned in to the dialect after a while, and it began to sound more authentic. (And one of the characters lives in Kirkintilloch – my very own little hometown!)

It picks up towards the end and, while the supernatural stuff is left hanging for the most part, the rest of it is explained, even if the credibility is stretched way past breaking point. Despite all the ridiculous stuff, it’s still very readable because of the overall quality of the writing. Although I really feel this one goes so far over the top it becomes farcical, I would be willing to read another in this series. I was reminded of the artist Agatha Troy, in Ngaio Marsh’s books, who never knew when one of her pictures was finished and needed her lover Roderick Alleyn to tell her when to stop painting. I really hope Meyrick can find an editor who will perform the same function for him (the stopping bit, not the lover-ing bit!) and tell him when enough is enough. Loads of potential in this series – I hope in future books to see it fulfilled.

Amazon UK Link
Amazon US Link

27 thoughts on “The Rat Stone Serenade by Denzil Meyrick

  1. Hmm….sounds like there are things to like about this one, FictionFan. I must confess, I’m not one for gore. But the past/present connection, the ‘is there a curse’ hint of the eerie, and the characters do sound interesting. So does the setting. Not sure about this one, but I can certainly see how you liked several things about it.


    • Yes, I could have lived without the corpse flaying myself! But overall it had quite a lot going for it in terms of place and characterisation so I wouldn’t rule out reading another in the future – hopefully, the author will realise he has enough going for him that he doesn’t have to throw the kitchen sink in… 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I’ve just read one that was like an Irish stew, everything thrown in, including evil twins, so I completely understand what you mean. I do like the setting and atmosphere of this one though (by the sounds of it).


    • Ha! Yes, at least this one didn’t have the evil twins thing – always such an original twist! 😉 Yes, I did like his writing and charcaterisation so hopefully as he gets more confident he’ll realise it’s not necessary to have quite so much going on. One to watch, maybe…


  3. Hmmm… I’m not one for Irish stew. Suppose I find peas in there! Ew. I can’t handle it. Sounds like there were some pluses, but again, I come back to finding a pea in there and it’s quite unacceptable!


    • Goodness, poor peas! What harm have they ever done you, huh? Haha! I read that as “Sounds like there were some pulses…” and felt even sorrier for the peas for a moment. Yes, there was too much in it for me – the individual ingredients were quite good but the final dish was just too much…

      Liked by 1 person

      • It’s the one vegetable I do not like. And come to find out, the Brits love them and incorporated mashed peas into nearly every dish! Yuk! I told my kids they never have to eat them, so I’ve sufficiently passed on my scorn for them. See how quickly I resorted to my immaturities? No wonder I like Catcher so much! hahah


        • Haha! I’m delighted to say mushy peas are an exclusively English delicacy – we Scots have a much more refined palate… deep-fried pizza, baked beans with everything… and then we spend zillions on research as to why we all die of heart disease…


  4. an anglicised speaker’s idea of what a generic Scottish dialect sounded like circa 1950 – a bit too Sunday Post

    Laughed aloud. Help, ma boab.

    The book sounds kind of fun, in its OTT way. If I see it, I may well pick it up.


    • Haha! I think there may well have been a help ma boab in there, and possibly a jings crivens too! The book is quite fun, and lots of people have rated it more highly than I have – go for it! I’m never very good at suspending my disbelief, so that put me off, but the writing’s pretty good.


  5. Well, gee, this one doesn’t sound like late-night reading before heading off to bed, does it?! I think I’ll pass. Like you said, too many bodies, and for me at least, not a big fan of reading dialect, whatever kind it is. Have a wonderful weekend, and hugs to Tommy and Tuppence!


    • Haha! The odd thing is that when a book goes as far over the top as this one it stops having any effect on me – I end up shrugging when the next flayed corpse turns up, or even giggling! Have a great weekend too, Debbie! 😀

      Liked by 1 person

    • It wouldn’t surprise me if there was a corpse in the kitchen sink too! Haha! It did have lots of good points, but the body count was a bit off-putting…


  6. Oh, it’s too bad that this one was spoiled by too much of everything. It’s promising that you liked the author’s writing style, though – perhaps he will get a better editor next time?


    • I hope so – it had so many good things about it, but it did get to the stage where I was kinda laughing every time another corpse turned up… not the intended reaction, I suspect! 😉

      Liked by 1 person

  7. I have started the book (as an audiobook) but I must admit I am not enjoying it.
    I find it slightly ridiculous and the characters just don’t grab me

    There are better Scottisg detective fiction books out there e.g The Stuart MacBride books set in Aberdeen


    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes, I really found it went way over the top and although I didn’t hate it, I’ve never found myself tempted to try any of his other books. I enjoyed the early Stuart MacBrides though I’ve kind of lost touch with the series recently. And I’m still a long-standing fan of Rebus!

      Sorry about the delay in replying – I’ve been on a little blogging hiatus. 🙂


Please leave a comment - I'd love to know who's visiting and what you think...of the post, of the book, of the blog, of life, of chocolate...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.