Five of the Best!



Each month this year, I’ll be looking back over my reviews of the past five years and picking out my favourite from each year. Cleo from Cleopatra Loves Books came up with this brilliant idea and kindly agreed to let me borrow it.

So here are my favourite July reads…click on the covers to go to the full reviews, though it must be said my early reviews were somewhat basic…




testament of a witchThis is the second in a series of historical crime novels set in the late 17th century just before the dawn of the Scottish Enlightenment. On checking it appears that the next one has just been released, 4 years later. Douglas Watt is a ‘proper’ historian, so one assumes his day job must have got in the way. This works excellently as a standalone, though – well written, historically insightful and with a solid plot based on the concerns of the time – treasonable plots, religious division, superstition and witch-hunts. Through the two main characters, rationalist John MacKenzie and Presbyterian Davie Scougall, Watt sheds a good deal of light on the political, religious and cultural concerns of the times and foreshadows the move towards Enlightenment thinking in the following century. But he doesn’t let the history get in the way of the story-telling, as MacKenzie must try to prevent the daughter of a friend from being burned as a witch.  The descriptions of how witches were identified and dealt with are both fascinating and horrifying. A couple of chapters are written in Scots dialect but not broadly enough to cause problems for a non-Scottish reader to understand.




shakespeare's restless worldThis set comprises 20 15-minute episodes in each of which Neil MacGregor (of A History of the World in 100 Objects fame) discusses an object from Shakespeare’s day, linking it to the plays or the theatres and also using it as a means to shed light on the society of the day.

MacGregor is excellent, clearly an enthusiast both for his subject and for sharing his knowledge. Each episode focuses on one object linked to an aspect of the plays – for example, a model ship leads us to the witches in MacBeth – and then MacGregor tells us of how that would have resonated at the time, when witches were still credited with the power of raising storms, causing shipwrecks etc. Every episode, though short, is packed full of information, interestingly told. If you prefer reading to listening, there is a book of the series, which is without exception the most lavishly illustrated book I own, and is a thing of beauty in itself.




burial rites

Set in Iceland in 1829, the book is a fictionalized account of the true story of Agnes Magnúsdóttir, condemned to die for her part in the murder of two men, one her lover. While waiting for the date of execution to be set, Agnes is put into the custody of Jón and Margrét Jónsson and, at Agnes’ request, a young priest, Reverend Tóti, is given the task of preparing Agnes spiritually for her death. At first the family are horrified to have a murderess amongst them, while Tóti doubts his own experience and ability to help Agnes find some kind of repentance and acceptance. But as summer fades into the long, harsh winter, Agnes gradually breaks her silence and begins to reveal her story of what led to that night…

Beautiful, sometimes poetic, writing, excellent characterisation and a haunting and heartbreaking plot, but what lifts this to the top ranks of literary fiction is the atmospheric depiction of the life and landscape of this remote community in the cold and dark of an Icelandic winter. A fabulous book that I felt was cheated by not being included on the shortlist for that year’s Booker.




the truth is a caveI described this book as stunning at the time and that still seems like the right word. A dark tale of a journey, a quest into the Black Mountains to find a cave – to find the truth – the story is equalled and enhanced by the amazingly atmospheric illustrations of Eddie Campbell. The two elements – words and pictures – are completely entwined. There’s no feeling of the one being an addition to the other – each is essential and together they form something magical. The story is by turns moving, mystical, dramatic, frightening; and the illustrations, many of them done in very dark colours, create a sense of mirky gloom and growing apprehension. Do click on the cover to see the review, where I included some pictures of the illustrations. As the story gets darker some of the later pictures are truly macabre and unforgettable. And the story itself is wonderfully haunting – one I remember very distinctly more than a year after reading it. I’ve read this in another collection without pictures, and it’s only about half as effective, so I strongly urge anyone who wants to read it to go for the graphic version – the paper one. A superb book.




sunset song 2Considered to be one of the greatest Scottish novels of the 20th century, this first volume of Lewis Grassic Gibbon’s trilogy, A Scots Quair, is a lament for the passing of a way of life. It tells the story of Chris Guthrie, daughter of a tenant farmer in the fictional estate of Kinraddie in the north-east of Scotland, before and during the First World War. Some of the writing is heart-breaking in its emotional intensity but never overloaded with mawkishness or sentimentality. As war approaches, Gibbon handles beautifully the gradual change within the community, from feeling completely detached and uninvolved to slowly finding their lives affected in every way. But he also shows that the community was changing already, with increasing mechanisation of farms, the landowners gradually driving the tenant farmers off as they found more profitable uses for the land, the English-ing of education leading to the loss of the old language and with it, old traditions. And as he brings his characters together once again after the war ends, we see them begin to gather the strength to face their uncertain future in a world that will never be the same again. A brilliant book that fully deserves its reputation.

24 thoughts on “Five of the Best!

  1. I like the look of Testament Of A Witch. I think I must be feeling a bit witchy today, in fact. I have been in a bad mood all day but this has cheered me up. Thanks, FF!

    • Aw, I hope your bad mood passes – that’s not like you! I think I’d quite like to be a witch – now that they’ve stopped burning them that is! But only if I could have proper magical powers…

      • I am feeling cheerier already, actually – thank you! Might be the wine and the fact I have chocolate brownies in the oven 😉
        I would like to be able to fly and turn people into frogs. I could do a lot of good with powers like that!

  2. I do like the look of these, FictionFan 🙂 . I started wanting to read Sunset Song when I first saw your review of it. And Shakespeare’s Restless World sounds absolutely fascinating. It’s so interesting to look at a writer and her or his work within the context of the times. Can’t say I’m too pleased about what this my do to my TBR thought *drums fingers. Pointed look at you.* 😉

  3. I’ve read two of your 5 star reads – Testament of a Witch – whilst I didn’t enjoy it quite as much as his earlier book, Death of a Chief, I was immersed into the fascinating and terrifying world of the witch-hunt in 17th century Scotland – I wasn’t too keen on the horrifying and explicit descriptions of how the witch hunter identified and dealt with women accused of being witches, which involved torture and sleep deprivation, but apart from that I enjoyed this book.

    I really loved Shakespeare’s Restless World – such a beautiful book that got 5 stars from me too.

    My TBR list is groaning already at the thought of adding yet more books, but I like the look of the other books too.

    • I never got around to Death of a Chief – every time I do one of these Five of the Best posts it reminds me of books I meant to read – and up goes the TBR again! Yes, the stuff about the witchhunting was pretty horrific, and very believable. Amazing to think it was still going on so late in Scotland.

      Shakespeare’s World is brilliant – I was really lucky to get both audio and book via Amazon Vine – I’m not sure which I preferred. MacGregor is great at narrating his own stuff – so enthusiastic – but then the illustrations in the book are fabulous!

      Haha! Only threee more – you can make room for those… 😉

  4. I’ve read all of these – all bar “Sunset Song” on your recommendation. I didn’t know Watt had written a third one – I can’t find it on Kindle, so I guess it must be fairly recent.

    • I only found out when I was checking for this post. I think it’s only out in paperback at the mo – that’d be why I missed it. I only check hardback new releases, though I rarely buy them in that format. Woo! You might be my best ‘customer’! 😉

  5. I’ve missed ALL of these!! Somehow, though, I lean toward Agnes’s tale this morning. Must be exorcising pent-up anger or something, ha! Anyway, thanks for a great review (and possibly some more selections to add to my own list!) Sorry I missed you yesterday — was beastly.

    • I checked once and discovered there are something like 400,000 books released every year – so it’s not surprising we all miss some! Burial Rights really is a great book – a crime element but definitely written like literary fiction – one of my favourite reads in years. Aw, I’m sorry – I hope everything’s OK again now… 🙂

  6. Burial Rites! Was she guilty? I probably asked this before. But I can’t help it at all, I fear. I’m just so curious about it. It sounds like a good book. The plot revealed little by little! Hope she got sprung out.

  7. All of those sound fascinating! I don’t know how I missed that Gaiman book last year!
    Burial Rites REALLY intrigues me! I’m going to have to start with that one.

    • Great choice! Burial Rites really is brilliant – unbelievable that it was her debut novel. And the Gaiman book is just wonderful – I don’t normally ‘do’ graphic novels, but I was blown away by it, both stories and pictures.

  8. Do you realise that your 2012,2013 AND 2014 ‘bests’ were all ones you successfully recommended to me too! Not quite sure they were my BEST reads of those years’ Julys, but they were all 5 stars. Mind you, I’d have to check what I was reading in July to be sure (to be sure)

    Do you realise you’ve just been nominated for a Lobster Award? Oops (cleans glasses) It’s a Tippler Award (cleans glasses again and pushes wineglass away) Well, something to do with Lobsters and Liquor. A Lobster Thermidor Award?

    I think I’m reeling at that 400,000 books published a year figure

    • *preens smugly* You should really just take my word for everything I recommend (American Pastoral…American Pastoral!). I’m always surprised by how long ago some of these books were – I tend to pick the ones that have remained freshest in my mind, on the grounds that that makes them ‘the best’. Unless of course they’ve stayed in my mind because of how much I hated them…

      That all sounds very fishy! I’m prawin’ it’s not a trick, ‘cos that might make me crabbit.

      Terrifying isn’t it? And I think that was just books published in English, though I may be wrong. Still, at least it means there’s unlikely to be a shortage…

Please leave a comment - I'd love to know who's visiting and what you think...of the post, of the book, of the blog, of life, of chocolate...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.