Capital Crimes: London Mysteries edited by Martin Edwards

capital crimes london mysteriesThe streets of London…

😀 😀 😀 😀 😀

From Sherlock Holmes to Lacey Flint, many of the detectives I have loved over the years have been based in London. And why not? One of the most cosmopolitan cities in the world with a history stretching back for over a millennium, it has always been a contrast of bright lights and dark alleyways, extreme wealth and desperate poverty, and every one of its ancient streets is drenched in the blood of the victims of its horrid past. Visitors love nothing more than to shiver in the London Dungeon, to thrill to the stories of ancient beheadings in the Tower, to make a pilgrimage to those famous rooms in Baker Street. What river has been the escape route for more criminals and the final resting place for more victims than the Thames? Who can think of Whitechapel without their thoughts turning to the eviscerated victims of Jack the Ripper?

london fog

So what better venue for a collection of classic crime stories? In this book, Martin Edwards has selected 17 stories from the Golden Age of crime writing, some from names we are still familiar with – Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Margery Allingham, Edgar Wallace – but many from authors who have since faded into obscurity. He has arranged them into rough chronological order, allowing us to see the gradual transition from the heyday of the amateur detective to the beginnings of the police procedural with which we’re more familiar today. The overall standard of the stories is variable, as in any collection, but I found most of them good or excellent, with only a couple that I felt really hadn’t stood the test of time. But even these added something to the collection in showing how trends were just as strong in early crime-writing as they are now. For example, I was underwhelmed by Richard Marsh’s The Finchley Puzzle, starring deaf, lip-reading amateur detective Judith Lee, but was intrigued to note that there seemed to be a fashion around that time for detectives with a physical quirk, since a couple of stories later we meet Ernest Bramah’s blind detective Max Carradine – not unlike our current obsession with autistic detectives, but happily without the angst (or drunkenness).

Martin Edwards
Martin Edwards

The influence of Holmes and Watson is clear in some of the partnerships between brilliant detectives and admiring narrators, (though I suppose I should grudgingly give the credit to Poe’s Dupin and his unnamed narrator really). R Austin Freeman’s Dr Thorndyke in particular struck me as very Sherlockian, as did the aforementioned Max Carradine.

Many of the stories rely on intricate plots – ‘locked room’ mysteries, innovative murder methods, unbreakable alibis, etc. But others veer more strongly towards the psychological, using atmosphere to great effect to build suspense, and a couple of them could easily be classed as horror as much as crime. I’ve already highlighted a couple of the stories as part of my Tuesday ‘Tec! slot – Edgar Wallace’s The Stealer of Marble and John Oxenham’s A Mystery of the Underground – but to give you a fuller flavour of the collection, here are a few more that stood out for me…

The Case of Lady Sannox by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle – this revenge story is definitely more horror than detection, telling the tale of a husband avenging himself against the man who is having an affair with his wife. A truly horrifying ending! And a great way to kick off the collection.

The Tea Leaf by Robert Eustace and Edgar Jepson – two men enter a room in a Turkish Bath, argue loudly, and only one leaves alive. But no murder weapon is found on the survivor or in the room. How was the murder done, and who is the killer? A fine example of a ‘locked room’ mystery with a unique method of killing.

The Little House by HC Bailey – amateur detective Reggie Fortune is asked to look into the case of a missing kitten, but this soon becomes an extremely chilling look at a case of child cruelty. The writing style is a bit staccato but the story is powerful with a strong sense of anger and justice.

The Case of Lady Sannox
The Case of Lady Sannox

The Silver Mask by Hugh Walpole – the story of the collection for me, and I will definitely be looking for more of Walpole’s work. This tells of a middle-aged lady whose loneliness and maternal feelings are played on by an unscrupulous young man. The way Walpole describes the woman’s character is very true and touching, and I found the portrayal of the unintended carelessness of her friends and family quite moving. This is another with an atmosphere of terror which mounts all the way through to an ending that is full of dread. Brilliant stuff!

They Don’t Wear Labels by EM Delafield – an intriguing story told from the perspective of the landlady of a married couple living in her lodging house. The woman is suffering from ‘nerves’ and on one evening tells the landlady her husband is trying to murder her. But the husband is so nice to everyone, and seems so kind to his impossible wife – he couldn’t possibly be a murderer…could he? Another psychological study this, of how one can never tell by appearances.

* * * * *

All round, an excellent collection that I highly recommend to all crime aficionados, and I’m looking forward to reading Edward’s selection in the companion volume, Resorting to Murder.

NB This book was provided for review by the publisher, Poisoned Pen Press, who publish the Kindle version. The paper version is part of the British Library’s Crime Classics series.

Amazon UK Link
Amazon US Link

48 thoughts on “Capital Crimes: London Mysteries edited by Martin Edwards

  1. Ah, you can’t go wrong with Martin Edwards at the helm, FictionFan. At least not in my opinion. And you’re absolutely right about London as a setting. Nothing quite like it anywhere else. Incidentally, have you read Edward Rutherfurd’s London? In my opinion, it’s a fantastic historical novel. Admittedly it’s long. But if you do enjoy those sweeping novels, I recommend it. I think he does a fantastic job of portraying the city.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Ooh Margot, I have to rudely jump in there, and wave MY high five too, for the Rutherford! I gather he repeated his formula with other cities, so reading additional Rutherford’s can get a bit ‘here we go again’, but, as someone who lives in London, I found it a superb educational read about my city and its history – all sweetly wrapped up in great, entertaining and absorbing narration. With you strong arming Fiction Fan on one side, and me on the other, she won’t stand a chance, unless she has already read it and can PROVE IT. Otherwise, it’s off to the Tower with her, unless it lands on the top of her TBR VERY SOON!

      Liked by 1 person

      • Good to know you’re with me on this, Lady Fancifull! I agree that Rutherfurd’s work is similarly structured across novels. But London is terrific! More than worth a read.
        Did you hear that, FictionFan? You might as well cede now and demonstrate that you have added this fine novel to your TBR, or that you have read it. We know where you blog! 😉

        Liked by 1 person

      • Now, look, I’ve ticked Margot off already and now I shall tell you the same – no ganging up on me!!! It’s not fair!!! Have you seen how long my TBR is? I just added all those Scottish books last week remember!! *sobs brokenly and adds the Rutherford*


  2. Who doesn’t love a locked room mystery, FF?? This sounds like a superb collection, and I’ll have to check it out further — thanks for the excellent review!


    • Yep, I love the more traditional style mysteries, and this was a good one – great murder method! The British Library are bringing out lots of great classic crimes stuff at the moment – hard to resist…


    • I love Conan Doyle – such a brilliant writer. He can do so many different styles equally well. This one was horrifying! I really enjoyed most of the stories, even the ‘less good’ ones. Have you got the companion collection – Resorting to Murder? Looks like it’ll be just as good…

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Okay, okay I surrender. Two for the TBR or the TBRR in two days. Sold to the weak willed woman who likes chocolate (could be all, or any of us, I suppose) A themed collection of very different stories like this sounds remarkably like one of the better class of chocolate selection boxes anyway. Several sound quite dark chocolate, and moreover with nutty kernels too!


  4. This sounds like one for me, although I have read quite a lot of them already. I’ve always been a big fan of Victorian/Edwardian crime, so I’m always glad to see these stories coming into print for a new generation.


    • There’s probably a couple you haven’t read – I’m sure he said in the intro that one or two of them had never been published before – not the best ones admittedly. The other book looks like fun too – murders in holiday resorts. (Probably all committed by Butlins chalet-maids… 😉 )


  5. Excellent review! The summer must be weakening my resolve. Love psychological and locked room mysteries…I can already feel my summer luggage getting heavier. Once of these days, I’ll have to buy a Kindle.


    • Thank you! The whole series is so tempting – I keep having to remind myself that there’s no point acquiring them unless I have time to read them… but I’m not sure I’ve convinced myself!


  6. I’m sure you’ve heard my wail of despair – I was doing so well, I’d even resisted this when you featured the odd story in the Tuesday ‘Tec but no more – I simply have to have a copy to put on my bookshelf – cue more anxious shuffling of books about! A fantastic round-up and I’m trying to forget that there is a companion copy.


    • Hurrah! I only have the Kindle version but this whole BL Crime series looks so nice I’d love to have a shelf full of them. Need a bigger house first though! I shall do my very best to ensure you end up with a matching set though… 😉

      Liked by 1 person

    • I love these older fashioned stories and the editor has picked some really good ones – none that I’d read before either. This whole Classic Crime series is looking great…


    • I love these anthologies for that reason – they give a real taster for how styles have changed. Looking forward to reading the companion piece about murders in holiday resorts too…


Please leave a comment - I'd love to know who's visiting and what you think...of the post, of the book, of the blog, of life, of chocolate...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.